Recently in Domestic Violence Orders of Protection Category

December 22, 2010

Whether Civil or Criminal, Domestic Violence Finding Has Severe Consequences

It is the unfortunate truth that divorce and child custody disputes can often lead to charges of domestic violence by or against either party.

In New Mexico, a single incident of reported domestic violence can result in criminal domestic violence and/or a civil domestic abuse case, either of which have serious consequences for the accused abuser.

The criminal domestic violence case is usually the result of the typical domestic violence call to the police or 911. Whenever the police are called on a domestic violence incident, one of the parties will be arrested if both are still present. Criminal charges are then filed against the arrested party. If the alleged abuser has left the premises, criminal charges will be filed without an arrest.

No matter how the charges are filed, the Court will almost always issue a no contact order that prevents the accused abuser/defendant from any contact with the victim. Typically, the court will also order the defendant to stay away from the alleged victim's home which is often also the home of the defendant.

In addition to criminal charges, the New Mexico Family Violence Protection Act allows a victim of domestic violence to file a civil case against the accused abuser by filing what is called a petition for order of protection. Upon filing the petition, an immediate temporary order of protection will be issued. Like the no-contact order in the criminal proceeding, the order of protection prevents any contact between the alleged abuser and the alleged victim. This civil proceeding can run concurrently with a criminal case.

In case of criminal charges, the case can go on for months. A civil case proceeds much more quickly. A hearing is set within ten days of service of the temporary order of protection and notice of hearing. In other words, once the alleged abuser receives notice of the allegations, an evidentiary hearing will be held for the court to determine whether or not the alleged abuser is guilty of an act of domestic violence. If domestic violence is found, a 6 month order of protection will be issued. This order may be extended for good cause.

Either a criminal conviction for domestic violence or a finding of domestic violence in family court have very serious and negative consequences on things like future employment options, the ability to carry a firearm, immigration status and even the ability to rent an apartment.

Either a criminal proceeding or civil proceeding will have many of the same negative collateral consequences. The severity of these consequences is why it is so important that parties on either side of a domestic violence action speak to an attorney to understand their rights, responsibilities and the consequences of a finding of domestic violence. It is equally important in both a criminal and civil proceeding.

Collins & Collins, P.C.
Albuquerque Attorneys


Bookmark and Share
December 21, 2010

Divorce, Hostile Shared Residence and Domestic Violence

One of the biggest sources of contention early on in a New Mexico divorce action is which party is going to leave the parties' marital home.

In New Mexico, a temporary domestic order is entered at the beginning of divorce which prevents either party from forcing the other to leave their shared residence. If both parties refuse to move out, then the court will have to enter an order determining who can stay and who must leave. This is not an easy issue in light of New Mexico's community property laws.

It may seem reasonable to just let the court decide who stays and who goes. In reality, it can take months, often many months, to get a hearing before the court on this issue. In the meantime, there are two people who are most likely not getting along very well attempting to live under the same roof.

While neither party may want to leave because they fear giving up a claim to the residence, the parties should also consider other damage that can occur when people who are arguing are forced to live together. This includes acts of domestic violence and sometimes false allegations of domestic violence.

Domestic violence can result in horrible physical and mental harm, and even in death. Domestic violence is a very serious problem and it is taken very seriously by law enforcement. In fact, law enforcement officers face some of their most serious officer safety issues in domestic violence situations. This accounts for the inevitable and sometimes seemingly illogical arrest of one of the parties on every domestic violence call.

A conviction for domestic violence or even an entry of an order of protection can result in permanent and irreparable damage to the alleged abuser. These include consequences for gun ownership or possession, employment, security clearance, property rental and immigration status among others.

These dour consequences result on a conviction or finding of guilt. Many times, it is the alleged victim's word against the alleged abuser. Is it really worth the risk in either case? The house is not worth a lifetime of disadvantage resulting from a finding of domestic violence.

Any sensible person faced with a choice of leaving the house, loss of pride, financial concerns or the like as opposed to a possible domestic violence situation should think seriously about moving on.

False allegations of domestic violence are hard to swallow for the alleged abuser. A true act of domestic violence is completely unacceptable and intolerable for the victim, law enforcement and the courts. Either way, living in a hostile home environment in the midst of divorce is truly flirting with disaster.

Collins & Collins, P.C.
Albuquerque Attorneys


Bookmark and Share
August 3, 2010

Consequences of a Domestic Violence Order of Protection Under the New Mexico Family Violence Protection Act

In New Mexico, the Family Violence Protection Act allows a victim of domestic violence to file a petition for order of protection, asking the Court to enter an order of protection preventing the person committing the domestic violence (called the restrained party) from having any contact with the abused party (called the protected party). Orders of protection are a specific type of civil restraining order and they can have a variety of consequences for all of the parties involved.

The primary consequence of an order of protection is that the restrained party cannot go within 100 yards of the protected party's home or workplace and must stay 25 yards away from the protected party in public. An order of protection may also prevent or regulate contact between any children that the parties may have together. The order of protection also prevents telephone, which includes texting, and e-mail contact between the parties.

All of these requirements will be explained in the actual order of protection; however, an order of protection has other consequences that are not as clear. If the order of protection is issued after a hearing at which the judge or special commissioner makes a formal finding of domestic violence, then the order may have long-term consequences on the restrained party's future employment opportunities, firearm rights, and immigration rights. The immigration consequences are perhaps the most serious of the collateral consequences since a finding of domestic violence may result in removal or deportation of the immigrant offender. Because of these very serious consequences, the parties may also agree to a Stipulated Order of Protection that does not include a finding of domestic violence.

Both types of orders of protection are filed with the National Crime Information Center (NCIC) so that they can be easily enforced by police across jurisdictions. In the case of a stipulated order, the restrained party is still prevented from any and all contact with the protected party and cannot possess a firearm while the stipulated order is in place, but there is no formal finding of domestic violence that would have to be reported later when applying for jobs, a firearms license or immigration procedures.

Finally, a violation of an order of protection can also result in criminal and civil penalties, including fines, jail time or both. Thus, if you are a party to a petition of order of protection, it is important that you discuss your case with an to make sure that the appropriate type of order of protection is entered and to ensure that it is properly enforced.

Sarah Armstrong
Albuquerque Attorney

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share
May 12, 2010

Two Sides to Every Story: Mutual Orders of Protection in New Mexico

In order to protect victims of domestic violence, the New Mexico legislature enacted the Family Violence Protection Act, which authorizes the courts to issue a type of civil restraining order called an Order of Protection. If an Order of Protection is entered, it prevents the person committing the domestic violence or abuse (called the Restrained Party) from having any contact with the victim of that abuse (called the Protected Party). A party that violates the provisions of an Order of Protection may face criminal and civil penalties. In some case, the Restrained Party may also be the victim of abuse by the alleged Protected Party.

The procedure under the Family Violence Protection Act requires that the a person be personally served with the Petition for Order of Protection before an Order of Protection may be entered against him or her. The alleged domestic violence offender must also be allowed to appear at a hearing to answer to the charges in the petition. If a Restrained Party believes that he or she is also a victim of abuse by the person filing the petition, then he or she may file a counter-petition informing the court of that abuse and asking that an Order of Protection be entered against the other party.

A counter-petition for an Order of Protection follows the same basic format as the petition and must be filed before the hearing on the original order of protection is held. If the court finds that both parties have committed domestic abuse against each other, it may enter what's called a Mutual Order of Protection, which means that both parties can face criminal and civil penalties for making contact with the other party. However, the court will not issue a Mutual Order of Protection if a counter-petition has not been filed. Thus, if a person is served with a petition for Order of Protection, it is important that they contact a New Mexico Divorce and Family Law Attorney immediately in order to ensure that they understand all of their legal rights, including the right to file a counter-petition.

Sarah Armstrong
Albuquerque Attorney

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share
April 29, 2010

Abuse of Domestic Violence Proceedings: Playing Dirty in Divorce

Under New Mexico law, a victim of domestic abuse can file a petition for order of protection asking the civil court to issue a restraining order (called the Order of Protection from Domestic Abuse) preventing the restrained party from contact with the abused party. The order of protection is an important mechanism available to protect victims of abuse. Unfortunately, as pointed out in recent columns in the Albuquerque Journal, the order of protection is often misused.

For instance, as part of a divorce proceeding, one party will often file a petition for order of protection even though no domestic abuse has occurred. The filing party may do this to prevent the other party from seeing their children or to force the other party from the marital residence. Or the filing party may just file the petition to cause the other party trouble because they then have to hire an attorney and miss work to appear at the hearing on the order of protection. Worse yet, the tactic can be used to literally ruin the other party.

The improper use of the order of protection can cost parties more than just time and money. A temporary order of protection is entered as a result of most petitions and although the temporary order does not make a finding of domestic violence, it is still part of the public record and may hinder the restrained party's ability to find employment or pass a background check. A finding of domestic violence has consequences far beyond the order of protection itself.

This misuse of the legal system is not only hard on the parties involved, but it puts the hearing officers and judges that review petitions for order of protection in a very difficult position. If the hearing officer issues a petition against a party that has not really committed domestic violence, then the restrained party can suffer serious and unfair consequences. On the other hand, if the hearing officer does not issue an order of protection and there really is domestic violence, then the life of the abused party could be in danger.

Given the frequent abuse of domestic violence proceedings, it is very important that parties on both sides consult an attorney prior to filing or immediately after being served with an order of protection. An innocent party's failure to do so may result in the entry of a bogus order of protection. A dishonest person filing a domestic violence action for wrongful purposes if found out by the court, can be facing numerous penalties including loss of child custody and time-sharing and findings of contempt with fines and awards of attorney fees. It is very dangerous game and should be treated as such by all.

Sarah Armstrong
Albuquerque Attorney

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share
April 1, 2010

Counter-Petition for Order of Protection from Domestic Violence

What if a Petition for an Order of Protection from domestic violence is filed against you, but you are actually the victim, rather than the perpetrator of the abuse? In New Mexico, you are allowed to file a Counter-Petition for Order of Protection from Domestic Abuse in which you can respond to the allegations in the original Petition while also asking the Court to enter an Order of Protection against the other party. In Albuquerque, the Counter-Petition can be filed at the Domestic Violence Office on the Second Floor of the Second Judicial District Courthouse.

The Counter-Petition must include all of the elements required of the original Petition for Order of Protection Against Domestic Abuse including a clear, detailed statement of the nature of the abuse and when and how it occurred. Remember that the definition of domestic abuse under Family Violence Protection Act is very broad. It includes incidents against a household resulting in: actual, physical harm, severe emotional distress, a threat that causes you to fear bodily injury and a variety of other situations. Also, remember that the definition of Household Member is very broad and can include a spouse, former spouse, any other family member (including present or former-stepparents or in-laws) and any other person with whom you have had an ongoing, personal relationship.

There should not be any cost for filing the Counter-Petition and the local sheriff is required to serve the Counter-Petition for free. If you are served with a Petition for Order of Protection and believe that you have grounds for a Counter-Petition it is imperative that you act quickly because hearings on the Petitions are typically held within a few weeks, if not days, of the issuance of the Petition. You will need to have the other party personally served with the Counter-Petition prior to that hearing so that the hearing officer or judge evaluating your case can hear both petitions. It is best to consult an attorney in any domestic violence situation, but at the very least you should got the courthouse where the original petition was filed to get more information about filing a Counter-Petition.

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share
February 23, 2010

Child Custody and Timesharing in Domestic Violence Actions

The essential component of a Domestic Violence Order of Protection under the New Mexico Family Violence Protection Act is the issuance of a restraining order prohibiting the restrained party from having any contact with the protected party/alleged victim. However, when the restrained party and the protected party have children together the domestic violence hearing officer can also issue short-term decisions regarding child custody, timesharing and child support. In Albuquerque, Rio Rancho and Santa Fe, the hearing officer will often refer the parties to the court clinic or family court services in order to evaluate custody and advise the court as to what is in the best interest of the children involved in the domestic violence case. The result is often a temporary parenting plan, the duration of which will depend upon the future behavior of the parties.

Albuquerque, Rio Rancho and Santa Fe each have a variety of court clinic and/or family court services for addressing child custody and time-sharing issues. These offices are staffed by trained psychologists, therapists and social workers who are often called court clinicians. The purpose of a court clinician is to help the judges and hearing officers make custody determinations by conducting an investigation into a child's living situation. This investigation, often referred to as a child custody evaluation, includes interviews of the parents, the child (if the child is old enough) and others involved in the child's daily life such as grandparents, teachers, doctors, counselors and even coaches.

Sometimes a hearing officer will ask a court clinician to appear at a hearing on an Order of Protection on very short notice for an on-call child custody evaluation. This is typically the case in custody matters related to domestic violence actions. In these situations, the hearing officer will call a recess from the hearing in order to allow the on-call clinician to speak to all of the parties present and make a child custody and timesharing recommendation that is in the child's best interest. If the on-call clinician determines that more investigation needs to be done they may ask the hearing officer to order a priority consultation which a more thorough but expedited custody evaluation. However, the on-call clinician will make interim recommendations based upon preliminary findings that will stand pending the priority consultation

A priority consultation is a more in-depth evaluation by the court clinician and will usually be held sometime after the domestic violence hearing. It may include interviewing others in the child's life not present in court at the domestic violence hearing and reviewing any relevant documentation about the parents' or the child's mental health. If the court clinician feels like still more investigation is needed, there may be a request that the hearing officer or the judge order that the parties participate in an advisory consultation, which often requires all the parties involved to undergo psychological testing and may span a period months, often many months due to the heavy caseload in the court clinic.

At the end of an on-call, priority or advisory consultation, the court clinician will make recommendations to the hearing officer or judge as to what the parties' timesharing arrangement should be. Each party has ten (10) days to object to the recommendations issued by the court clinician. If no objections are filed within the 10 day time period, the recommendations are adopted as an order of the Court.

A hearing on an Order of Protection can have lasting effects on a restrained party's liberty and their right to see their children, which make is extremely important that you consult an attorney if a Petition for Order of Protection is filed against you. Every case is unique and requires individual analysis to protect both your interests and the interests of your children. No matter which side you are on, it is typically inadvisable to attend these hearings without a New Mexico divorce and family law attorney.

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share
February 15, 2010

Domestic Violence Orders of Protection Under New Mexico's Family Violence Protection Act

A domestic violence order of protection is a type of restraining order issued to protect victims of domestic violence under New Mexico's Family Violence Protection Act. Domestic violence cases in New Mexico are often filed in criminal court where the penal consequences can be severe. The Family Violence Protection Act provides another layer of protection for alleged victims of domestic violence in New Mew Mexico civil courts.

Though these cases are filed in civil court, a finding of domestic violence has very serious consequences. As such, it is imperative that anyone facing one of these proceedings consult with an attorney, and have one present at the hearing if at all possible.

After an alleged victim of domestic abuse (called the Protected Party) files a Petition for Order of Protection Against Domestic Abuse alleging that another person (called the Restrained Party) has committed an act of domestic abuse, the court will issue a Temporary Order of Protection against the Restrained Party and order both parties to appear at a hearing.

The Temporary Order of Protection forbids the Restrained Party from any contact with the Protected Party until the hearing. This often means that a Restrained Party cannot return to their home and it also prohibits contact by telephone, e-mail and texting.

Though an Order of Protection is not a criminal action, a Restrained Party who violates the Order of Protection in any way can be charged with a crime. In addition, the Restrained Party can also be charged with contempt of court and jailed until a hearing is held. In serious domestic violence cases, the judge can hold the Restrained Party following the hearing under its contempt powers. So if you are served with an Order of Protection, it is very important that you read the terms of the Order carefully and strictly obey them.

At the hearing, which should occur quickly after the filing of the Petition, the court will decide whether or not an act of domestic abuse has occurred. Depending on where you live, the hearing may be presided over by a judge, a hearing officer or a special commissioner. In Albuquerque, Santa Fe and Rio Rancho, these hearings are heard by Domestic Violence Hearing Officers. If the presiding official makes a finding that domestic abuse has occurred, the can issue an extended Order of Protection that extends for 6 months. The alleged victim may file a Motion to Extend Domestic Violenc Order of Protection in cases where there is an ongoing threat of domestic violence.

As stated, a finding of domestic violence can have serious long-term implications, including registration as domestic violence offender, prohibitions on gun ownership, deportation, bars to certain employment including any job requiring a firearm, and problems with security clearance which is often most serious of all in New Mexico. Further, the extended Order of Protection not only prevents the Restrained Party from contacting the Protected Party, but it can also include provisions regarding custody of children, distribution of property and can order the parties involved to attend counseling.

Parties to a Petition for Order of Protection may want to consider agreeing to a Stipulated Order of Protection, which can allow them to avoid a finding of domestic violence while allowing the alleged victim all the protections of an Order of Protection. This will avoid the finding of domestic violence and most of the consequences outlined above. In most cases, this is not only best for the Restrained party but also for the alleged victim since a domestic violence finding will often result in the loss of employment and loss of support for the alleged victim and the children to the relationship.

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share
January 11, 2010

What is the Role of a Guardian Ad Litem in New Mexico Child Custody Cases?

A Guardian Ad Litem, often referred to as GAL, is a person appointed by the Court to represent the interests of a minor or a person who is unable to represent themselves by virtue of age or incompetence. In the case of child custody actions, the GAL is appointed to insure that the interests of the children are protected.

As in all child custody cases, the standard in New Mexico is the "best interests of the child." This is often hotly contested between the parties. In fact, if a GAL has been appointed, then the case probably has a very high level of conflict between the parties as to what is best for the children. Otherwise, there is no need for the GAL.

A GAL's job is to advocate zealously for their clients, which in this case is the children. The duty to represent the children is just as high as with any client. In high conflict child custody cases involving a GAL, the GAL can at times be overzealous often causing additional strain between the parties, and therefore on the child.

The GAL also acts as an investigative tool for the Court and, depending on the Court's order, may be charged with investigating the health care providers, teachers, coaches, counselors and others familiar with the child. As an arm of the court, what the GAL says goes. Therefore, if the parents cannot agree, the GAL decides and 9 times out of 10, the court will follow the advice of the GAL. This basically takes all the parenting decisions away from the parents where the parents cannot agree.

In New Mexico, a Judge may appoint a GAL in a wide variety of cases, including cases wherein a child has been a victim of abuse or neglect. Most often the GAL is appointed because the judge is fed up with the parties and the use of the GAL is the only option remaining for sorting out what is best for the children.

It is in your best interests and the best interests of your children to try to work with the other parent to work out a parenting plan without the intervention of a GAL. If a GAL is appointed, which we usually resist unless absolutely unavoidable, then you are in for a long, contentious, invasive and emotionally stressful ride. If that is not enough, the costs of the GAL will likely far exceed the costs of your attorney.

Do yourself, your children and your wallet a favor, work things out with the other parent. The GAL path is one you want to avoid at all costs. Once you have gone down that path, there is often very little left to salvage for you, your ex, or the children.

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share
December 21, 2009

What is a Domestic Violence Order of Protection?

An order of protection is a type of restraining order issued to protect victims of domestic violence that is authorized by the Family Violence Protection Act. An Order of Protection basically prohibits contact between an alleged victim and the person the alleged abuser.

After an alleged victim of domestic violence (called the Protected Party) files a Petition alleging that another person (called the Restrained Party) has committed an act of domestic abuse, the court will issue a Temporary Order of Protection against the Restrained Party and order both parties to appear at a hearing.

The Temporary Order of Protection forbids the Restrained Party from any contact with the Protected Party until the hearing. This often means that a Restrained Party cannot return to their home and it also prohibits contact by telephone, e-mail and texting.

A Petition for Order of Protection is not a criminal action. However, a Restrained Party who violates the Order of Protection in any way is subject to immediate arrest. In addition, the person can be subject to both criminal charges and contempt of court . So if you are served with an Order of Protection, it is very important that you read the terms of the Order carefully and strictly obey them.

At the hearing, which should occur quickly after the filing of the Petition, the court will decide whether or not an act of domestic abuse has occurred. Depending on where you live, the hearing may be presided over by a judge, a hearing officer or a special commissioner. If the presiding official makes a finding that domestic abuse has occurred, the court will issue an extended Order of Protection for 6 months. The Order can be extended for up to a year for good cause with Motion to Extend the Order of Protection Against Domestic Violence.

A finding of domestic violence can have serious long-term implications, including prohibiting a Restrained Party from ever possessing a firearm. A finding of domestic violence can have serious immigration consequences resulting in the initiation of removal proceedings and eventual deportation of an offending immigrant. Finally, a finding of domestic violence will often bar certain types of employment and more often than not will have grave consequences for governmental security clearances.

The parties to a Petition for Order of Protection may want to consider agreeing to a Stipulated Order of Protection, which can allow them to avoid some of the consequences of a finding of domestic violence. After all, the consequences outlined above can be devastating to both the party found guilty of domestic violence as well as the alleged victim who is often left with no means of financial support for her and the children.

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share
December 15, 2009

Consequences of a Finding of Domestic Violence in Family Court

After an alleged victim (the Protected Party) of domestic violence has filed a Petition for Order of Protection and the Temporary Order of Protection has been entered preventing the alleged abuser (the Restrained Party) from any contact with the alleged victim, the court holds hearing to determine whether or not the Petition provides enough information for the court make a formal finding that domestic abuse has occurred.

These petitions are often filed in the context of a divorce or custody battle. However, they can be filed by any "household member" as defined under the statute. The Family Violence Protection Act statute defines household member as follows:

"household member" means a spouse; former spouse; family member, including a relative, parent, present or former stepparent, present or former in-law, child or co-parent of a child; or a person with whom the petitioner has had a continuing personal relationship. Cohabitation is not necessary to be deemed a household member for purposes of this section."

A parent can also file a Petition in order to protect their minor child. The court must find that a preponderance of the evidence provided at the hearing shows that an act of domestic abuse has occurred.

According to the Family Violence Protection Act, the definition of domestic abuse is very broad, but it basically defined as an incident by a household member against another household member and includes things like actual physical harm, severe emotional distress or just making a threat that causes the Protected Party reasonably think that the Restrained Party might harm them.

A finding of domestic abused can have serious implications. The court records of these civil domestic violence Petitions are not accessible to the public in New Mexico, however, all Orders of Protection are reported to the database maintained by the National Crime Information Center (NCIC), which is accessible to all law enforcement agencies in the country. A finding of domestic violence results in registry in the database as a domestic violence offender.

Registry as a domestic violence offender has numerous severe consequences. The full faith and credit clause requires that every state recognize and enforce the Orders of Protection issued by another state. Many employers, especially for jobs that require any kind of security clearance, will request that a potential employee report whether or not any findings of domestic abuse or violence have ever been made against them. And, under the federal gun control regulation, a finding of domestic abuse will prevent a Restrained Party from ever owning or possessing a firearm. This includes firearms used in hunting. It also includes firearms used in the course of law enforcement and the military effectively barring domestic violence offenders from law enforcement and military service in the absence of waivers. Finally, a finding of domestic violence serious immigration consequences including immigration removal proceedings for deportation and exclusion of the domestic violence offender from the United States.

Due to the severe consequences of a fidnign of domestic violence and the rather liberal burdens and rules of evidence in domestic violence hearings, the parties to a Petition may want to enter into a Stipulated Order of Protection, in which the Restrained Party agrees to comply with an extended Order of Protection, but a full evidentiary hearing is not held and there is no finding of domestic abuse. Both the alleged victim and the alleged abuser benefit from this arrangement particularly in cases where there are support issues. After all, it does little good to have family's provider fired from his job or worse, deported from the United States.

A party facing the a Petition for Order of Protection from Domestic Violence should discuss the implications of a finding of domestic violence and a Stipulated Order of Protection with their attorney or the court itself at the prior to the beginning of the hearing.

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share
December 12, 2009

Filing and Defending Domestic Violence Orders of Protection in New Mexico

A Domestic Violence Order of Protection is a type of restraining order issued to protect victims of domestic violence and abuse, which is authorized by the Family Violence Protection Act. In New Mexico, including Albuquerque, Rio Rancho and Santa Fe, anyone can file a Petition for an Order of Protection at the Domestic Violence office on the second floor of the Second Judicial District Courthouse. It is not necessary to have an attorney to file a Domestic Violence Order of Protection.

By statute, the Court cannot charge the alleged victim (called the Protected Party) for filing the Petition and the sheriff's office cannot charge a fee for serving the alleged abuser (called the Restrained Party) with Petition and Temporary Order of Protection.

A Domestic Violence Order of Protection is separate from criminal domestic violence charges that are filed in metropolitan, magistrate or district court. In cases of criminal domestic violence actions, the police or district attorney's office will file domestic violence criminal charges based on an alleged incident of abuse in a criminal case. In a Petition for an Order of Protection from Domestic Violence is filed by the alleged or his/her attorney. ,

It is possible for criminal charges and an Order of Protection to arise from the same incident. These Petitions for Order of Protection Against Domestic Violence are often filed during a divorce proceeding or a custody dispute. Unfortunately, these petitions are often used as a weapon in a divorce or custody matter with no real basis for the petition. A party accused of an act of domestic abuse may file a response to the Petition or may also file a Counter-Petition against the party alleging the abuse.

The standard required to file a Petition is very low. Essentially, a Protected Party just has to swear to the court that they have been a victim of domestic abuse and describe the abuse in the Petition. Then the court will issue a Temporary Order of Protection, which means that the Restrained Party cannot have any contact with the Protected Party.
The Petition and Temporary Order must be personally served on the Restrained Party and the Order will set a hearing when the alleged abuser must appear before the court.

Many jurisdiction, including Albuquerque's Second Judicial District and Santa Fe's First Judicial District, have appointed designated domestic violence hearing officers or special commissioners to hold the hearings on Petitions for Orders of Protection. The hearing officer or special commissioner will hear all the evidence and issue all the findings at the hearing and then issue a report that the presiding district court judge will approve.

All testimony at these hearings is on the record and under oath. Either party may have an attorney, but unlike criminal proceedings, an attorney is not provided for you by the State. The Protected Party has the burden of showing the court by a preponderance of the evidence that an incident of domestic abuse has occurred. Preponderance of the evidence basically means that it is more likely than not that domestic abuse occurred. This is a fairly low burden unlike the burden in criminal cases. In addition, the rules of evidence and procedure can be a little lax in domestic violence hearings. It is therefore necessary to defend the actions pretty aggressively if the allegations are without merit.

Should the hearing officer find that domestic violence has occurred, an Order of Protection will be issued for a 6 month period. These Orders can be extended for an additional 6 months through the filing of a Motion to Extend Order of Protection upon a showing of good cause.

Either party may file objections to the Hearing Officer's findings and report within 10 days of the issuance of the report. The matter will then be reheard before a District Court Judge.

www.CollinsAttorneys.com

Bookmark and Share